Don't Lose Money Twice: How to Handle Business "Losses" and Use Them For a Tax Benefit
The reality of entrepreneurship is that not every year
is profitable. Whether you are a first-year solopreneur with heavy startup
costs or an established small business owner facing a major economic downturn,
the year-end realization that your expenses exceeded your revenue can be
disheartening. It feels like losing money once.
However, the greatest mistake a business owner can
make is failing to utilize these legitimate financial setbacks as a strategic
tool. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) and other tax authorities around the
world recognize that losses happen, and they provide specific mechanisms—most
notably the Net Operating Loss (NOL) rules—that allow you to turn a current
business loss into a future, or even past, tax advantage.
![]() |
| Don't lose Monet Twice |
This is the principle of: Don't Lose Money Twice.
This comprehensive guide, anchored in the (Taxes)
section, provides a precise roadmap for understanding, calculating, and
deploying your business losses. We will detail how to handle business losses
for tax benefit, explain the current rules surrounding NOL, and outline a
strategic approach for maximizing your deductions as part of effective business
income tax planning.
Phase 1: Defining a Business Loss (The Taxable Difference)
A "business loss" for tax purposes is not
just when your gross revenue is low. It is defined specifically as the amount
by which your deductible business expenses exceed your taxable business income
for the tax year.
1. The Legitimate Deduction Requirement
To qualify for any loss benefit, every expense must be
"ordinary and necessary" for your trade or business.
Crucial Action: Ensure that you have meticulously
documented all your deductible expenses—from software subscriptions and
home office deductions to professional development and marketing costs. In the
early years, the goal is to fully recognize these startup costs to accelerate
the loss declaration.
2. The Distinction Between Business Loss and Personal Loss
The IRS is highly vigilant regarding "hobby
losses." Your business must be operated with a genuine profit motive to
claim a loss.
The Nine Factors: The IRS uses nine factors to
determine if an activity is a hobby (non-deductible loss) or a business
(deductible loss). These include: maintaining accurate books, dedicating
significant time, relying on the income, and demonstrating expertise.
The Takeaway: If you claim losses for three
consecutive years, you may face heightened scrutiny. Maintain professional
books and treat your venture like a business, even if it is currently losing
money.
Phase 2: Deploying the Net Operating Loss (NOL) Strategy
The Net Operating Loss (NOL) is the primary mechanism
by which the small business owner turns a loss into a tax reduction tool.
3. Understanding the Modern NOL Rules
The rules governing when and how you can use an NOL
were significantly changed by the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) of 2017 and
subsequently modified by the CARES Act of 2020.
A. Carryback Elimination (Generally)
For losses arising in tax years beginning after 2017,
the ability to "carry back" (use the loss to claim a refund from a
prior profitable year) was largely eliminated for non-farm businesses. (The
CARES Act provided a temporary 5-year carryback for losses from 2018, 2019, and
2020, but this expired.)
B. Carryforward Indefinitely (The New Standard)
The NOL must now generally be "carried
forward"—used to offset taxable income in future profitable years. The
benefit does not expire.
C. The 80% Limitation
The NOL deduction is generally limited to 80% of your
taxable income in the year you use it. This means you cannot use the NOL to
eliminate your future tax liability entirely; you will always pay tax on at
least 20% of your future profit.
4. How the NOL Strategy Works
The NOL strategy is a simple, yet powerful, tool for business
income tax planning.
Scenario: Your business loses $20,000 in Year 1 (your
NOL). In Year 2, your business makes a profit of $50,000.
The Benefit: Instead of paying tax on the full $50,000
profit in Year 2, you can use your $20,000 NOL to reduce your taxable income.
The Calculation: $\$50,000 \text{(Profit)} - (\$20,000
\text{(NOL)}) = \$30,000 \text {(Taxable Income)} $. You just reduced your tax
bill by saving the tax on $20,000—the exact amount you lost. This is the
ultimate example of how to handle business losses for tax benefit.
Phase 3: Passive Losses and Self-Employment Specifics
For solopreneurs and service-based professionals, two
additional rules often complicate the business losses strategy.
The Passive Activity Loss (PAL) Rules
The IRS distinguishes between "active"
losses (where you materially participate in the business) and
"passive" losses (from rental activities or businesses where you do
not materially participate).
The Rule: Passive losses can generally only be
deducted against passive income. They cannot be used to offset your salary from
another job or active business income.
The Solopreneur Check: For a typical freelancer, your
business is usually considered an "active" activity, meaning your
losses can offset other forms of personal income (e.g., your spouse's W-2
income, subject to the Excess Business Loss rules below). Ensure your
documentation clearly shows your material participation (over 500 hours per
year).
6. The Excess Business Loss (EBL) Limitation
For taxpayers who are not corporations, the
TCJA introduced the Excess Business Loss (EBL) rule, which severely limits the
amount of business loss you can deduct in a single year against your
non-business income.
The Limitation: For 2025, the EBL is approximately
$314,000 for single filers and $628,000 for joint filers (these numbers are
adjusted for inflation). Any loss exceeding this cap is disallowed in the
current year.
The Treatment: This disallowed loss is then treated as
an NOL and carried forward, subject to the 80% limitation.
The Impact: While this primarily affects very large
businesses, it is essential for high-net-worth small business owners to be
aware that even if your loss is active, it cannot be used to fully offset an
unlimited amount of non-business income.
Phase 4: Strategic Loss Planning (The CPA's Playbook)
Effective business income tax planning involves
strategically timing expenses and income to maximize the NOL benefit.
7. The Loss-Harvesting Strategy
If your business is near break-even, you may want to
strategically "harvest" a small loss in the current year if you
anticipate a massive profit in the following year.
The Tactic: Defer invoicing (pushing revenue into the
next year) and accelerate necessary, large expenses (paying for software or
equipment in advance) to manufacture a small NOL.
The Benefit: This manufactured NOL can then be used in
the high-profit year to reduce your overall tax burden, providing significant tax
savings precisely when you need it. This is how you master the don't lose money
twice tax strategy.
8. Documenting the NOL for the Future
Because an NOL can be carried forward indefinitely,
meticulous documentation is required to avoid problems years down the line.
The Need: Maintain a clear, separate schedule
detailing the exact NOL amount, the year it originated, and the amount used
each subsequent year.
The Tool: Rely on professional accounting software and
a CPA to handle the calculation on Form 1045 or Form 3800. Do not attempt complex NOL
calculations manually.
Conclusion: Transform Risk into Reward
A business loss is painful, but it is not a dead end.
By understanding the rules governing the Net Operating Loss (NOL) and the
limitations like the Excess Business Loss (EBL), you can transform a negative
financial event into a positive tax advantage.
The goal of this strategic business income tax
planning is simple: use your current legitimate losses to legally reduce your
future tax bill. Stop viewing losses as a failure; view them as a valuable
financial asset to be managed and deployed. Ensure you don't lose money twice—use
your losses to fuel future profitability.
